Essential KPIs for Nonprofits
Measuring Success: Key Performance Indicators
A strong financial foundation is essential for any nonprofit organization. While mission-driven organizations often prioritize their community impact, having a solid financial base is crucial to achieving their goals. Key performance indicators (KPIs) provide valuable insights into an organization’s financial health, enabling leadership and boards to make informed decisions.

Donor Retention Rate
This metric measures the loyalty of existing donors. Given the cost and effort involved in acquiring new donors, maintaining year-over-year support is crucial. A higher donor retention rate indicates effective stewardship and engagement.
Fundraising Effectiveness
Donors and funders are primarily interested in two aspects: the total contributed revenue and the portion of each dollar that funds programs. This KPI assesses fundraising efficiency, measuring the percentage of each dollar spent on securing donations.
Current Ratio
This ratio indicates an organization’s ability to meet short-term obligations with current resources. A ratio of at least one-to-one is ideal. A lower ratio may signal cash flow difficulties.
Debt to Net Assets Ratio
This ratio measures an organization’s debt relative to its assets. A ratio below one-to-one is preferable, as a higher ratio may indicate excessive debt.
Average Gift Size
This KPI measures the average value of donations received. It can serve as a valuable goal-setting metric, motivating the team to increase the level of donations.
Implementing and Prioritizing KPIs
By tracking and analyzing these KPIs, nonprofits can strengthen their financial foundation, set meaningful goals, foster better discussions about strategic efforts, and encourage staff engagement. Understanding your organization’s performance in these areas is essential for sustainable growth and effective mission delivery.
Brady Ware Nonprofit Advisors want to help you fulfill your mission with financial health and compliance services and a network of nonprofit consultants who specialize in strategic decision-making.
Questions?
Chelsea’s background in audit and assurance enables her to provide specialized accounting services to nonprofit organizations.